Dealing with Depression – Your Guide to Best & Worst Supplements
Posted on 17. Mar, 2011admin in Depression, Health issues
The multi-billion dollars worth nutritional supplement market is bursting with a plethora of product types claiming to be mood-boosters or alleviate depression. Billing of several of the brand names are also done as a substitute to prescription-only antidepressant medicines.
Never make the mistake of believing all that’s mentioned on the labelling. Mostly assertions by supplement makers do not have strong medical proof to back them & the effectiveness & constituents of supplements differ significantly. Many of them are far from innate. When dealing with depression of the serious kind, seeking assistance from experts is of utmost importance, if or not this entails antidepressants drugs.
That stated, a number of supplement types like Saint John’s Wort & S-adenosyl-L-methionine (SAMe) have undergone quite extensive testing & might bring about symptom improvement for those dealing with depression of the milder form or associated conditions like SAD (seasonal affective disorder).
Here’s a split up of the proof or shortage of it backing majority of the supplements deployed for dealing with depression & mood.
Folic Acid
Folic Acid (also called as folacin, vitamin Bc or vitamin B9) is a synthetic folate type present in several types of fruit, leafy veggies & other types of foods which affect the monoamines, the brain trio neurotransmitters (norepinephrine, serotonin & dopamine). It is available in capsular or pill form in the market.
Proof
Deficits of folate are prevalent among depression sufferers, particularly ones not responding to antidepressant drugs. Testing of Folic acid as a solitary depression therapy hasn’t yet been done, however its comparison with dummy as an inclusion to Prozac has been evaluated. During a trial, depression sufferers receiving folic acid showed improved response as compared to the placebo-takers – however solely in women patients. Almost ninety-five percent of females receiving folic acid showed response to the combination therapy in comparison to around sixty percent of female placebo-users.
Gist
The proof for folic acid usage in treating depression is restricted & non-conclusive. 5-Methyltetrahydrofolate & an associated type of folate known as optimized folate or l-methylfolate – that is obtainable as Deplin – an orally administered prescription medical food – might be beneficial as an adjunct to antidepressant medicines, however, one must be cautious about non-prescription brands which have these duos as the key constituent.
GABA
Gamma aminobutyric acid (GABA) is an amino acid present in the CNS and functions as an inhibitory neurotransmitter & stress respite. It is vended in capsular, tablet or powder form.
Proof
Depleted presence of GABA in the body has been associated with depression & nervousness. Though supplement manufacturers assert on their labelling that GABA helps in supporting upbeat & tranquil mood, there’s absence of proof that these supplements would be having any affect on depression signs & symptoms, there’s absence of human trials been done till present.
The proof for its usage for anxiety is not strong enough. Some smaller-scaled trials carried out by a Japanese GABA manufacturer cited that it did help in tackling anxiety. During the foremost trial, the scientists noted that its intake had an unwinding impact on brain signals. During another trial, individuals fearful of height were requested on walking across a constricted pedestrians bridge subsequent to have taken the supplement or a dummy. GABA-users had lesser extent of nervousness (measurement via stress moniker in salivary sample).
Gist
A link amid innately present GABA & nervousness & depression has been proven. Though prescribed drugs like Depakote (an anti-seizure drug deployed for bipolar disorder) & benzodiazepine (anti-anxiety treatment) are known to be affecting GABA level, there’s hardly any proof of how commercially present supplemental GABA would be impacting moods in the analogous way.
Inositol
It is an optically in-active alcohol which is a constituent of B-complex vitamin that promotes neurotrasmitter conduction. Individuals would be ingesting around one gm. inositol daily from fruit & veggies, meats, wholegrain & other forms of food & is additionally vended in capsular & powdery form.
Proof
Lower-than-avg. amounts of inositol have been observed in the brain of depressed people or bipolar sufferers that then spurred scientists into investigating if inositol in supplemental form can assist in treating depression.
The preliminary study showed promise. A smaller-scaled trial appearing in the mid-nineties noted that the intake of twelve gm. inositol daily – a quantity comparable to a handful of pills vended in shops – brought about improvement in depression symptoms more effectually as compared to dummy. Astonishingly, none have ever attempted at replicating such triumph. Rather scientists have examined if inositol improves the effects of antidepressant or mood-stabilizer medicines – & these trials noted no variation amid dummy & inositol.
Gist
Inositol’s efficacy hasn’t yet been corroborated. Additional studies might still disclose usages for it; however in the interim specialists warn against its usage as depression supplement.
Omega-3 Fatty Acids
Also known as ?-3 fatty acids have DHA & EPA as constituents that are vital for brain functioning & heart health. Coalesced in approximately analogous quantities, DHA & EPA are the key constituents of fish oil, however they are even vended in formulations containing higher levels of one as compared to the other.
Proof
An association amid ?-3 fatty acids intake & moods is backed by duo key sources of proof – Depressed individuals have been found to be having lesser amounts of ?-3 fatty acids & nations eating ample fishes/ capita like Japanese have lesser depression rate.
The studies done on ?-3 fatty acids is assorted, but in many RCTs, DHA, EPA or a combo of the duo have been fond to allay bipolar & depressive symptoms superiorly as compared to dummy – however in almost all of these trials, the ?-3 fatty acids were included with antidepressants or mood-stabilizer drugs, hence it is not clear if ?-3 fatty acids as stand-alone has an effect. During a latest trial appearing in JAMA, ?-3 fatty acids as well as Zoloft were observed to be faring superlatively as compared to dummy and Zoloft in combo.
The duo trials which deployed ?-3 fatty acids as stand-alone treatment for depression have yielded assorted outcomes. One noted that duo gm. DHA daily taken for 6 weeks wasn’t better as compared to dummy, the second trial – that was carried out in kids of the age six to twelve noted that a combo of DHA & EPA outshines dummy.
Gist
Though some of the trials on ?-3 fatty acids & mood conditions do show promise, it says nebulous as to how effectual ?-3 fatty acids are, & what formula & combo of therapies would be benefiting the best. However, ?-3 fatty acids have lesser side-effects & are beneficial to the heart; hence they could be worthwhile for trying (though always seek medical advice firstly).
Saffron
A flavoursome food spice obtained from the crocus plant’s dry stigma & even a traditionally used medication in Persia for treating depression symptoms & several health problems. Though saffron in supplemental form could be obtainable on the net, they are not as commonly obtainable.
Proof
There’s hardly any studies been done on the impact of this spice on moods. However a string of small-scaled Iranian RCT’s done some years back on saffron were found to be work astonishingly fine in the treatment of mild to medium range depression. Distributed in thirty mg dosages daily, this spice has outshone dummy & has illustrated depression-combating effects at par with imipramine (earlier used tricyclics) & Prozac, in the interim use.
Gist
Though further studies are necessary, it seems to be a potential therapy for mild to medium ranging depression.
SAMe
SAMe (S-adenosylmethionine) is an innately present compound affecting brain neurotransmitters. In the U.S. they are obtainable as OTC since the late-nineties.
Proof
Lesser amounts of SAMe in the body has been linked to depression. During trials, SAMe has been found to be almost as effectual as tricyclics drugs (an earlier group of prescription antidepressant drugs). However, in several of such trials, administration of SAMe was done in jab form & it isn’t clear if its oral intake in capsular form have the analogous impact.
During a re-assessment of the trials done on depression & SAMe nine years back by the AHRQ came to the conclusion that they had no greater efficacy as compared to dummy in allaying depression signs & neither superior to or inferior to tricyclic medicines. Further studies on orally taken types of SAMe are warranted & study contrasting SAMe to latest antidepressant medicines like SSRI types is necessary.
Gist
SAMe has been established to be beneficial in treating depression; however queries regarding its general efficacy & delivery techniques stay. They do have a few side-effects, most apparently exacerbating hypomania among bipolar sufferers; hence these are to be taken only after consulting with a doctor.
Saint Johns Wort
It is a yellowish blossoming plant which has been deployed for medicinal reasons since long & an alternative therapy for depressed people for ten or more years.
Proof
It has been a highly researched alternative cure for depressed people & mostly outcomes have been positive. During trials, milder & moderate-ranging cases of depression was found to consistently benefit from the use of Saint John’s Wort and has even been found to have analogous or better efficacy as compared to Celexa, Prozac & imipramine.
Its efficacy in acute depression cases has been queried, though. A popular trial on moderately acute depression sufferers noted that Zoloft or Saint John Wort weren’t considerably more effectual as compared to dummy.
Gist
In mild-ranging depression, its efficacy could match up to antidepressant medicines. Though it has usually lesser side-effects, however it could be interacting with other medications. Hence, checking with a physician prior to commencing its use is advisable.
Tryptophan
It aids in the production of serotonin neurotransmitter and available in OTC capsular version as 5-HTP & L-tryptophan.
Proof
Researches have found a link amid depleted level of tryptophan & depression signs (particularly in females), however the proof for its usage in supplemental form is less. Although in a reassessment of trials done on tryptophan found that it outshone dummy however they were smaller-scaled ones.
There have been worries regarding how safe the supplemental form is since in 1990 the United States FDA ordered a temporary pull out of any L-tryptophan product from the market when over 1500 individuals taking it were observed to develop eosinophilia myalgia syndrome. Finally, over twenty-four deaths were reported.
Gist
The general proof is non-conclusive & safety worries exist.





Leave a reply